Couple of weeks ago, I blogged about security cameras. Rather, I blogged to ask about them because I know nothing. I got some very good info, including the chance to look through the “eyes” of several security cameras. (Thank you, S and D — and D, I just love the doormat that says “Leave.”)
MJR, who knows a thing or three about security systems, posted a link to a company called 2MCCTV.
Somebody at 2MCCTV was watching their Web traffic. That quick, I heard from a friendly 2MCCTV rep named Clint Henderson, offering guest blogging. Who am I to turn down an offer to do my work for me? Especially when I might also learn something.
I asked Clint a few questions, and here are his answers:
Q: Until recently, I’d have thought of security camera systems as being only for rich people, businesses, or perhaps homeowners with high-crime problems. Suddenly it seems that lots of ordinary homeowners and renters are getting them. Who is your typical customer and why are they buying your equipment?
A: Our clientèle includes corporate and enterprise-level businesses as well as individual homeowners looking for complete security camera systems.
Our typical homeowner clients are middle-class, not overly wealthy, who are primarily using the equipment for live monitoring inside and outside their homes.
Many have recently been robbed. By buying a security system, they hope to prevent similar incidents from happening in the future. Other customers just like to know what’s going on at their home at all times.
Q: What is a realistic minimum cost for setting up a security-camera system in a typical home?
A: For a small 4-camera system, they typically start out at $500. That would include cameras, DVR recorder, and CCTV cables. This would of course not include the installation.
If you’ve looked around the web and seen these $150 pre-packaged systems on Amazon or eBay, remember that you get what you pay for. The quality is very low, but more than that, surveillance systems are not one size fits all. I would never recommend getting any sort of low-cost pre-packaged system, as you’d more than likely find yourself getting frustrated and look to something else anyway.
PRO TIP: You can lower your overall cost by using an old monitor you already have, instead of purchasing one included in a system.
Q: Backwoods Home people tend to be do-it-yourselfers and my readers tend to be tech-savvy. Is it reasonable for people to set up their own systems or do you think this should be done by a professional?
A. With a standard analog security surveillance system, running wire, mounting, and connecting cameras is very straight-forward. There are plenty of how-to guide videos on the internet (for example, here is a video on how to run wire by eHowTech). It is my belief that a person with any type of intermediate DIY skill-set would be able to figure it out. Here is a basic guide for powering your cctv equipment you may want to check out.
But like any DIY project, speak with a professional before committing yourself fully.
PRO TIP: Connectors are inexpensive, but rare. You won’t be able to find them at Home Depot or Wal-Mart, so make sure you order more than enough when buying your system.
Q: What are the advantages/disadvantages of wireless (wifi) systems vs wired systems?
A. We almost always recommend getting a hard-wired system. Here are just some of the advantages of wireless security cameras:
- Hard-wired systems have virtually no interference. With wireless security camera systems, there are always concerns with possible video signal interference.
- Hard-wired CCTV surveillance systems will be less expensive. Granted, wireless cameras have come a long way, but you’ll still find yourself spending quite a bit more for them.
- Hard-wired systems have extra features that most wireless cameras won’t have.
- Hard-wired will have better resolution.
- Hard-wired cameras will have a much longer range. For wireless, there are significant distance limitations.
The only advantage to wireless, literally, is that you do not have to run a wire.
One thing to remember is that the “wireless” part refers only to the video signal, the actual data transmission. The camera still needs to be powered electrically through a wire.
Q: Personally, I would like to have features like motion-detection, night vision, and sound capture (and not just when using Windows as a control system). I would also like motion-detection to be selective, so the camera wouldn’t be catching my dogs going in and out their doggie door. How possible is all this? And especially how possible is it on a budget?
A. For night vision, you want to get a camera with infrared LEDs. The LEDs emit an infrared light which is captured by the camera lens in black and white. Even the least expensive cameras can come with infrared LEDs.
Sound is best captured using a separate microphone component piece for the audio surveillance. They are not terribly expensive. Most DVRs support audio, but the number of channels is often limited. If you need more than one channel, select a CCTV DVR with the number of audio inputs you will require.
Motion detection is built-in for all standalone DVR recorders. Consider it a standard feature for all these systems. As far as blocking out the unwanted movement, it’s called standard “masking” and this feature also comes standard with pretty much all standalone DVRs. You just need to select which area on your screen that you want to mask. Another feature for the doggie door is sensitivity. Sensitivity settings control at what threshold a unit will be activated. For example, you can lower the sensitivity so that a bird flying across the screen would not be detected, but a man walking would be.
These features all come standard and shouldn’t affect your budget.
PRO TIP: Computer-based DVRs have far more functionality and features than standalone DVRs.
Q: Your website has a dizzying array of products, including more types of cameras than I knew existed. (I’m particularly fond of the hidden camera/alarm clock in the shape of a puppy.) What’s your best advice for helping people sort through all the choices without becoming completely confused?
Call us. This is paramount. It’s free to get our professional input.
Every case is unique and everyone’s application is going to be different than the next person’s.
The product is not most important. The application is. So you need a professional who can match the product with your unique application.
Speaking to the categories listed on our website, here’s a little navigational tip if you want to look around yourself: The most popular cameras are infrared bullet, infrared dome, vandal-proof dome, and PTZ (pan/tilt/zoom), especially at consumer level electronics. (Here’s a link to 2MCCTV’s main security camera page)
—–
NOTE: I have NFI in any products from 2MCCTV.




Security cameras have interested me for a long time. They have always managed to stay slightly more expensive than I could afford. This thread has caused me to think about it some more. There are definite security advantages to be gained from having your property under surveillance. I am beginning to realize that there are downsides as well.
Recently I’ve been thinking about how everywhere you go there are cameras watching. I would be a little creeped out to visit friends only to discover I was on camera. I would be less inclined to go there after that, I think. I really don’t want to deceive my friends by using hidden cameras as I would be offended if others did that to me. I would love to see public funded surveillance cameras cease to exist and therefore I really don’t want to contribute to the surveillance state by adding to the number of cameras.
I live in a remote area and my security needs are therefore reduced compared to city/suburban folks. There are some threats, of course, but minor ones. So for me the cost/benefit ratio (social as well as economic) doesn’t justify installing cameras.
That’s my story and I’m sticking to it (until I change my mind again). 🙂
Just a word of caution here Claire. I have four of them in and around my business quarters. My town had an annual public event last July that featured some drunken “wilding” behavior during the night and the cops swung by my place the next day and wanted to copy the feed from the night hours. Expect that same degree of intrusiveness from defense and litigation lawyers too if it hasn’t already. Just sayin’.
Maybe try to find very small, easily hidden cameras? Like the “lipstick” type? Can’t bash what you can’t see. I’ve considered getting cameras, but what I want is something easily hidden-to prevent any potential intruder from simply bashing them, as well as what Ken K just said.
At my last job, they had “hidden”cameras disguised as smoke detectors-the problem being they didn’t look like the rest of the smoke detectors! Might as well had a sign on them that said “Hidden Camera Here”.
You guys all make good points (and Ken K, yours is one I never considered — but I’d still guess is pretty rare; ugh, though).
But in my case, the simple fact is that I live in a not-great neighborhood and I’d like to have cameras both so that potential bad guys will see them and say, “Never mind,” and to have a record if somebody decides to give me grief despite them.
I agree surveillance has a huge creep-out factor — but much moreso when it’s done secretly or it can’t be avoided. My friends almost never drop in unexpectedly; I could turn the cameras off for them.
@Clint or anybody else who’s got a lot of experience, can you tell me how weatherproof these are? I see cams outside of businesses and wonder how often they have to be replaced because water gets into them or the cold cracks something. I have a semi protected spot but I want to be able to hang a camera and forget about it.
Karel,
If a camera is installed correctly, it will basically be waterproof for the life of the camera. There are times when a manufacturer has a design defect and water can get in but they will replace them under their warranty (if reported during the warranty period). Working here I have seen cameras installed improperly (not by us) and that resulted in water damage. Normal rain will not be a problem for cameras designed to be outside. FYI cameras will have an “IP Rating” which denoted their resistance to water. I have included a link to a chart defining them. http://www.2mcctv.com/blog/2011_10_11-ip-rating-chart/
Personally, I’ve always been a fan of misdirection.
Give thugs something they expect to see – an easily-visible, inexpensive, camera. That’s the decoy. Then back it up with a hidden cam that actually records stuff.
If they decide to block, break, or disable the ‘camera’, they’ll think they’ve handled the situation – and won’t bother looking for your real one.
But that’s just me.
been years since i commented, maybe not since the old blog, claire, but this subject interests me. i’ve started looking around for security systems but a lot seems over my head. so many questions! i’ll start with two here and hope somebody can answer them.
dome cameras, bullet cameras, ptz, etc — does anybody have a link to a page that tells which of those is best to use in what application?
then if you live in a small town or rural area as a lot of us do but you’re not confident of your own abilities to do electrical work, can a regular electrician install a camera system or would i have to have a specialist come from far away?
Just some thoughts…
Battery backups for your system? Power outages would be an idea time for criminals and you’d be out of luck if you’re counting on cameras. Me? I’ll count on my dog instead. 🙂
There’s rain… and there’s cold. I’d make sure the cameras and system you install is actually able to withstand the climate you live in. What might do fine in the alleged rain of a Texas city home might be damaged by the combination of -20 temps and spring thaws/heavy rain somewhere else. Doesn’t hurt to ask.
Fallingwater,
There are a couple of different questions here so I want to make sure I touch on all of them. Firstly the question about types and uses of cameras is best answered by speaking to a pro about your needs. They will be able to address the correct product you need and explain their choices (if they are good). Here is a blog that does touch on that topic. http://www.2mcctv.com/blog/2012_07_04-bullet-cameras-vs-dome-cameras/.
As far as your question about installation, it is my belief that any competent electrician will have no issue installing the product physically. The cameras are powered through low voltage and running wire is what they do for a living. Programming the DVR or certain settings of the camera may be a little new to them but the instructions will be pretty helpful. Also the vendor of the equipment should be able to answer any questions (if they are good). On a personal level we have sold many systems to ordinary DIYers and they have been successful.
I appreciate Clint’s comments. I’m just a user of both wired and wireless cameras, I don’t sell them. I must respectfully disagree with a few claims.
“Hard-wired systems have virtually no interference. With wireless security camera systems, there are always concerns with possible video signal interference.”
Both types are subject to interference. There is nothing magic about wires. FWIW, I’ve never experienced interference on my wireless cams, but I have on my wired ones.
“Hard-wired CCTV surveillance systems will be less expensive.”
Only if you value the time and labor to run the wires at zero.
“Hard-wired systems have extra features that most wireless cameras won’t have.” Specifics, please. My Panasonic wireless cams have way more features than my cheaper wired cams. There is nothing inherent in a wireless cam that limits features.
“Hard-wired will have better resolution.”
I call BS on this one. You can get HD cams in both wired and wireless. Megapixel cams in both. You get what you pay for, again there’s nothing the inherently limits the resolution of a wireless cam.
“Hard-wired cameras will have a much longer range. For wireless, there are significant distance limitations. ”
Those limits might matter in some applications, but they simply aren’t a factor in mine.
There is also the problem with lightning. Lightning kills wired cams with amazing frequency. Wireless are all but immune, so long as you have protected the electric power supply. But those long wires that give the advantage of longer range make perfect antennas to carry a lethal impulse to both the cams and the DVR. This is the voice of experience speaking.
Mamaliberty,
Battery backups are a great idea, but affordable ones are only good for about 15 minutes. The ones at office supply stores are really designed to give a person the time to safely shutdown their equipment. So keep that in mind when designing a system.
When it comes to cold all I can revert to is anecdotal evidence, but for as long as I have been doing this I have never had a customer call back and say a camera failed because of cold.
Thank you, Clint, for your comments. I looked around there at your place, and noticed ‘vandal proof’ cameras. So I’m just wondering what that means. Have they been tested against strikes with baseball bats? How about .177 CO2 pistol fire? Bic lighter and a can of WD-40? Bonus points if you employed actual Vandals in your testing, in which case please let me know where you found the flux capacitors.
Here’s an article that details how not to go into the FEMA camps.
http://fromthetrenchesworldreport.com/how-to-avoid-getting-trapped-in-fema-camps/21414/
As for watching for drones, I’d get a pair of night vision scopes that can detect IRs and keep as low a profile as I can.
If you need a laugh, take a look at this.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlokPJO2h-Y&feature=youtube_gdata_player
Clint… sort of my point… Anything that requires continued power is going to be of questionable value in any prolonged power outage. Those with serious solar systems and the attendant batteries would fare better, of course.
I suspect that cameras, motion detectors, lights and so forth could be very valuable in many cases, but total reliance on such things might be a temptation. Seems anyone who installs cameras needs a plan B… and C… 🙂
As for the cold tolerance of the cameras, that’s great – and frankly amazing. I have simple motion detection lights on my deck, and they often will not come on if the temp is below zero. No idea what’s up with that. 🙂
Jed,
That is a great question and I am glad you brought it up. “Vandal Proof” is a term created by camera manufacturers. It is a standard industry term for that style and we have to use, but it is not accurate. VP domes are weather resistant and “Vandal resistant”.
To answer your question, no they will not withstand any of that. If a person can get face to face with a camera they will be able to destroy it, or in the case of the lighter and WD40 burn it down with the house. More extreme cameras exist (bullet proof, explosion proof, etc.) but they are rare.
As for the Flux Capacitor, we are meeting Doc Brown at the Twin Pines Mall tonight ( I will skateboard there). Hopefully everything will work out well.
S,
Thanks for your response, and yes, it sounds like you do have experience. The audience of Living Freedom seems to be quite diverse, with a varying level of expertise.
I agree with most of your claims. A hard-wired system can have interference, wireless cams can work perfectly fine, and HD cameras have been manufactured to fit multiple applications.
I am speaking from experience and using the feedback of our customers over the years. For instance, far more of our customers have complained of interference issues with wireless than hard-wired.
To us, it’s not just about the technology. It’s also about the responses we’ve heard and catering to the needs of our customers.