Press "Enter" to skip to content

Being well-informed amid media madness, part II

Mark Twain (is alleged to have) quipped, “If you don’t read the newspaper, you’re uninformed. If you read the newspaper, you’re mis-informed.”

Borepatch, upon consideration of our current condition, amended that to, “If you don’t follow the media, you are uninformed. If you do follow the media you are both uninformed and misinformed.”

Got a point there, Brother Borepatch.

On the other hand, there’s also this possibility: If you don’t follow the media, you might be far better informed.

—–

I gave up TV on December 27, 1994 and never looked back. I’ve been unable to do the same for the Internet. Even after banishing Comcast from my home, I’ve never broken my news-junkie habit and can still find ways to click myself down infotainment rabbit holes.

In part, this is a side-effect of the fact that I need to be online to do my work — and don’t most of us, these days? Work or keeping in touch with family or organizing community events or taking a class or researching. There’s always something that keeps most of us online. And once we’re here they’ve got us — “they” being the Usual Suspects of Big Tech and the “news” media.

What a powerful indicator of just how addictive this business is. Even when you know the “news” is a slough of toxic bull byproducts, you still want to dive into the latest leavings. (At least I do, and I know I’m not alone.)

What may finally break the addiction is how completely useless “news” has become recently, as covered in part I and as we all see more clearly every day. “News” may still be compelling, as Charles Dana Gibson noticed a century ago (note that the headline drawing all eyes is all about murder and mayhem; some things never change). But informative? Not so much.

—–

So what to do to stay informed in this era of media madness? Let me count some ways.

1. Being informed doesn’t necessarily imply being up on current events. How about being informed on philosophy, community activities, the history of art, world records, historic sports scores, the education of your children, great books, emergency medicine, the world’s most peaceful vacation spots, sewing techniques, home workshop gun-making (traditional or 3D printed), the latest developments in psychedelic therapy, saving heirloom seeds, or astrophysics (to name just a few)? Current events are fleeting and virtually every word of “news” about them is either dead wrong or from a severely canted viewpoint. How lovely to be informed on something you can use for a lifetime and share (not just grouse about) with others.

2. We are in-formed by our choices. Most modern dictionaries don’t even mention it, but there used to be a different common definition of the word “informed.” You’ll still hear it once in a while from elegantly literate people. Informed means “formed by” — as in what we do or experience or eat or believe or consume through our eyes and ears forms who we are. Information itself isn’t necessarily informative. While having a head full of trivia is good for writers and Jeopardy contestants (of which, you’ll notice, there’s a considerable overlap), having too much URGENT! crap pouring daily into our brains keeps us from seriously learning, absorbing, thinking, and synthesizing. Next time I’m tempted to click, I’m going to ask, “Do I want my life and values formed by this?

3. Rest. Sleep. Rest, relaxation, and good sleep aren’t just pleasant and necessary for our health. They keep our brains well-tuned. How many times have you been banging your head on a problem, walked away, “slept on it,” and awakened with an answer, or at least a new approach to solving it? Let’s use some of our mindless clicking time to catch a nap or go for the full eight hours and see how clearer life looks afterward.

4. By the same token, have a life. Ever had that same lovely clarity and peace from, say, taking a walk, sitting in the sun with friends, caring for animals, planting a garden, building a shed, getting engrossed in a hobby, painting a picture, reading a book, doing a favor for someone who appreciates it, taking a swim, or otherwise doing something in the real world? Yeah. How ’bout we do more of that?

5. If we gotta be online, let’s make it count. Let’s set our own priorities for what we want to know and do — that is, what we genuinely want to be informed about and what we want to be formed by. Great schools offer free courses online. Museums give virtual tours. We can learn computer security from experts. Study poetry or examine classical artworks in extreme high-resolution. Learn to speak Irish Gaelic, Spanish, or Chaucer’s English. Find out about the latest discoveries in volcanology, archeology, or paleontology. I don’t recall who originated it or what the exact quote is, but somebody once remarked that we now have a tiny device that lets us access the entirety of the world’s knowledge — and we use it to watch cat videos and argue with strangers. … And let’s add to click on spurious “news.” (Oh, by the way, when I tried to find the quote and its source, two of the first three links that came up on DuckDuckGo were on “how to argue with cats.” Yes, the Internet is a strange, strange place. For once I resisted going down a rabbit hole.)

6. Create your own newsfeed. Using Feedly or something like it, curate yourself a small collection of “news” sources and blogs that don’t drive you crazy. Be sure to include a significant number of humor sites or cheerful, inspiring ones. Then make this your only source of online news. (I know a lot of you already have daily feeds, but the trick is to follow only those links and not go clicking at random into places that either waste your time or raise your blood pressure. And yes, that is a trick. Otherwise, a personal feed just adds to the brain clutter.)

7. Set up “adult filters” on our computers and phones. If disciplining ourselves not to click, not to get sucked in to online garbage “news” is too hard (and I confess for me it often is, especially when I’m tired), then how about creating “adult filters” for our online use? That could mean setting our computers to block virtually all news and opinion content. It could mean setting up a strict schedule for our online time (say, no more than two hours a day, or no Internet on weekends, whatever works). If all else fails, unplug and lock the tempting device away during whatever hours you choose to put off limits.

That seems like a pretty good beginning.

—–

Got additional ideas, or better ones? Jump into the comment section and post away …

18 Comments

  1. Jeff2
    Jeff2 April 20, 2021 4:43 am

    This is something I have been struggling with. Working toward more spiritual things. Life, family, the world around me. I have been turning my internet focus towards the spiritual sites and self improvement. But, I still feel the need to keep abreat of the situtaion, though I rarely go to MSM for info. I would like to disconnect entirely but fear being caught by surprise by the latest edicts.

    I guess fear is the issue, though I have little fear of death. My main fear is failing in my support of my family. I would be VERY disconnected if not for that.

    I trust I will receive the guidance I need to do the best that I can. Much of that guidance comes from sites like this and people like you.

    Thanks for all that you give us and all of those who share here and add knowldge and understanding to the world.

    Jeff2

  2. Simon Templar
    Simon Templar April 20, 2021 5:14 am

    According to this site, which may or may not be reliable:

    https://marktwainstudies.com/the-apocryphal-twain-if-you-dont-read-the-newspaper-youre-uninformed-if-you-do-youre-misinformed/

    the Mark Twain quote about newspapers is likely an “apocryphal aphorism,” although the point is still quite valid, possibly even more so now than it was in Twain’s day. The entire site is short, and might be worth reading, but here are a couple of interesting paragraphs:

    “For reasons that remain unclear, the attribution to Twain became common practice in 2007. Over the next couple years, the aphorism was repeatedly used as a crutch for lazy columnists. Thus emerges a meta-irony which Twain would undoubtedly have appreciated: newspaper writers writing in newspapers about the unreliability of newspaper writing and citing an unreliable source to testify to that unreliability.”*

    . . .

    “Though he was critical of both institutions, Twain would undoubtedly agree with Jefferson, who wrote, “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have government without newspapers or newspapers without government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.””**

    * I do not intend any offense to either Claire or Borepatch, both of whom I read regularly, and neither of whom I would consider lazy. But the irony is there, nonetheless.

    ** While I have not seen the letter and so cannot vouch for it personally, Thomas Jefferson apparently did write this in a letter to Edward Carrington, dated 16 January 1787, according to the research I was able to do online:

    https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-11-02-0047

  3. Comrade X
    Comrade X April 20, 2021 7:07 am

    Good points all in all!

    I have been trying to reduce my internet time but it is a one step at a time thing more than the 12 steps methinks.

    More reading does seem to benefit too.

    Sleeping on it does work, many times when I hit a wall, walking away from that wall helps me to see how easy it is to get over/around it when I come back, I’ve also even have taken a few tokes in my pause time and found many many answers but for some reason I can’t remember them later, I discovered writing them down when they are conceived helps.

    Not to make you want to go down another cat hole but I did find the video;

  4. Comrade X
    Comrade X April 20, 2021 7:12 am

    Good points all in all!

    I have been trying to reduce my internet time but it is a one step at a time thing more than the 12 steps methinks.

    More reading does seem to benefit too.

    Sleeping on it does work, many times when I hit a wall, walking away from that wall helps me to see how easy it is to get over/around it when I come back, I’ve also even have taken a few tokes in my pause time and found many many answers but for some reason I can’t remember them later, but I discovered writing them down when they are conceived helps.

    Not to make you want to go down another cat hole but I did find the video;

  5. Claire
    Claire April 20, 2021 7:14 am

    Simon Templar — No offense taken. On the contrary, thank you for the correction. I’ll add a link to your comment where I refer to Twain.

  6. Granny
    Granny April 20, 2021 7:16 am

    Rabbit holes: I have been down many and poof! half the day is gone and anxiety has increased tenfold. I try to discipline myself to reading “the news” online for a quick 20 minutes in the morning from sites I choose. For instance, the big trial going on (won’t mention names) may spark even more riots and mayhem. That information will inform what areas of the country to avoid as I take a trip across the country in the near future. Then, I shut down the computer and get to work on projects and things of interest. During the day I want to stray back to “reading the news”, so I have to smack myself to stay away from it. Having no television is helpful! Easy Internet access is not helpful. LOL. I’ve often wondered if there would be benefits to an EMP crashing the Internet and setting us all free. That wouldn’t help everyone who works online now, but we’d all be forced to structure our lives without it, and I remember those days – the pace was slower, we got outside more, we interacted more, we physically did more things, etc. It was a calmer time for sure.

  7. Claire
    Claire April 20, 2021 7:20 am

    I would like to disconnect entirely but fear being caught by surprise by the latest edicts.

    I guess fear is the issue, though I have little fear of death. My main fear is failing in my support of my family. I would be VERY disconnected if not for that.

    You nailed it. Aside from the sheer addictive properties of the ‘Net, I think fear of not seeing or being able to protect against whatever might be coming at us is a very big factor for most of us who stay connected despite ourselves.

    Thanks for all that you give us and all of those who share here and add knowldge and understanding to the world.

    That’s kind of you and those are welcome words. But it’s the proverbial two-way street. I get as much from you as you do from me.

  8. Bear
    Bear April 20, 2021 10:27 am

    Sadly, for my work, I HAVE to check a LOT of “news,” mainstream and alt. That’ll tell me SOMETHING happened, then I go do the research and ask the questions that the “reporters” mostly won’t.*

    But I consciously walk away from the computer every hour or so. I keep LOLCats bookmarked to decompress when it gets bad.Babylon Bee is also helpful. And I STOP working every evening; if I’m online after that it’s for entertainment or an emergency. I’m largely avoiding social media. I have multiple accounts, but I stopped using them a month ago (and I was suspended from Twitter back in September 2020). Weekends are for fun, not work. Eh, mostly.

    —–
    Current case in point: Marion County prosecutor is lying about why the FedEx shooter wasn’t “red flagged.” “News simply reports that they didn’t want to. I called him out of that, because they were REQUIRED to by IC 35-47-14-3. Now the prosecutor is claiming they didn’t have time. But the second the officer took the shotgun, he was REQUIRED to immediately file an affidavit with the court explaining why he did it. No one in the “real” media is touching that; so I do it for those who really want to know. Too bad I don’t have more readers.

  9. Toirdhealbheach Beucail
    Toirdhealbheach Beucail April 20, 2021 5:09 pm

    Claire, those are all very solid recommendations. For what it is worth, MIT has a host of class on line and available for free – one author, Scott Young, got the equivalent of an MS in Computer Science using this (his book Ultralearning, if you have not read it, is well worth the time).

    My downfall is current events – and by current, I mean “right now”. I remember driving to work one morning – just like every morning – and I had just cleared the first toll bridge I had to cross when the radio announced a plane had hit the World Trade Center. As I continued to drive, they kept announcing: Tower Two, the Pentagon, Shanksville PA. I was completely floored – not only by the events, but by the fact that I had seen none of this coming: had no background really in current world events or ideologies as I was burrowed into my own little life. It made me agree with myself never to be caught flat footed again.

    I am also a victim of rabbit holes, especially reading history – I will start with Alexander the Great, then start on his major battles and generals, and suddenly I am in Sicily with the Athenians and Carthaginians 30 years earlier, contesting the island (Battle of the Crimissus, 339 BC, in case you were wondering).

    Maybe the only suggestion I could make is also avoid looking at comments in articles or stories. Read the story or article for the content but do not get drawn into the war of words.

    Echoing Jeff, thank you so much for kindness and generosity in sharing such things. Reliable and helpful information is very hard to come by these days, especially when it effectively comes without an agenda except “Think for yourself”.

  10. Daylan
    Daylan April 21, 2021 7:19 pm

    I was starting to feel a bit of Self-Righteousness (because I’m not a new ‘junkie, nor rarely explore rabbit-holes), but then I realized I just had a different (not better, not worse) waste-of-time vice; online blitz chess. It is just a couple minutes, and then another couple minutes, and then “Where did those last 3 hours go?”.

    Hello, my name is Daylan, and I’m an addict…

  11. Claire
    Claire April 22, 2021 12:00 pm

    Curious as to why you ask, Randall Saunders.

    Wikipedia says: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_token

    A security token is a peripheral device used to gain access to an electronically restricted resource. The token is used in addition to or in place of a password. It acts like an electronic key to access something. Examples include a wireless keycard opening a locked door, or in the case of a customer trying to access their bank account online, the use of a bank-provided token can prove that the customer is who they claim to be.

    Some tokens may store cryptographic keys that may be used to generate a digital signature, or biometric data, such as fingerprint details. Some may also store passwords.[1] Some designs incorporate tamper resistant packaging, while others may include small keypads to allow entry of a PIN or a simple button to start a generating routine with some display capability to show a generated key number. Connected tokens utilize a variety of interfaces including USB, near-field communication (NFC), radio-frequency identification (RFID), or Bluetooth.

    I suppose if you depended on a security token for access to your computer, you could hide the thing from yourself. Otherwise, you’ve got me curious as to how it relates.

  12. Randall Saunders
    Randall Saunders April 22, 2021 1:14 pm

    I was interested because when I tried to post earlier I was denied with the message, “bad security token.” I have no idea why. It let me post this question. Could it have been the http: links in the original post?

  13. Randall Saunders
    Randall Saunders April 22, 2021 2:05 pm

    Some suggestions:

    Perhaps some would find use for the Education & Knowledge resources from the Free Individual. https://usabig.com/:

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/education_online.html Education online, free to everyone, about 16 free souces for all levels of education, including MIT and Stanford.

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/research.html Research Resources with over 30 online sources on almost anything from history to science.

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/site_reviews.html” Site Review Links to over 350 freedom and individualism sites. (Good resource for anyone doing a “Blogroll.”)

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/books.html Books–over 20 sources of books, many free online.

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/books_authors.html Books (Reference) lists hundreds of books really worth having and reading, with links.

    https://usabig.com/iindv/articles_stand/FS/freedom_library.html Freedom Library lists the most important writer in history dealing with freedom and individualism with links totheir works online where possible.

    I hope these are helpful.

  14. Claire
    Claire April 22, 2021 2:25 pm

    “I was interested because when I tried to post earlier I was denied with the message, “bad security token.” I have no idea why. It let me post this question. Could it have been the http: links in the original post?”

    I’m sorry that happened to you, and I have no idea why you’d get a message like that. I do have HTTPS Everywhere on my browser, and I give links as https rather than http when available. And yes, you would get a message something to the effect of “secure site not available” if the linked site had only http. But “bad security token”? Hm. Stumped me there.

  15. Randall Saunders
    Randall Saunders April 22, 2021 4:56 pm

    “But “bad security token”? Hm. Stumped me there.”

    No worries. Had to be something I did. Sorry to have interrupted the discussion, and hope the links I provided will help some be, “informed.”

    I totally agree that most people have let their minds be filled with popular trivia to the neglect of what is truly of value to them. My wife and I have not owned TV since before 2000. It’s a kind of freedom we made for ourselves, as all freedom has to be.

Leave a Reply